利大于弊

弊大于利

　　我直接阐述观点。在自由辩论环节，还会进一步展开。

　　I hope the Bill that mobile phones are for middle school students. First, it can provide us with great learning resources and improve our learning efficiency. Also, it helps us connect with our parents and friends and enhances our interaction with others. So, I think the mobile phone is a very useful tool.

　　直观地感受10秒，这相当于你的I部分。

　　当我开始时，有点紧张。I convince that mobile phones will cause some people to become addicted to them. It will cause some rifts in important relationships, just like with your parents. Also, if you are indulged in it and use your phone to play games instead of studying, it has some disadvantages.

　　开始。等一下，不是，我去展开浏览的时候，是我自己再补充观点。你补充观点，补充论据。刚刚费雨娜说了能 connect parents，还能作为我们学习的工具，你就不能说这两点了，要补充其他观点。

　　这挺有意思的，这让我想到，一般他们是有准备的，会写稿子，咱们没写稿子也正常。我看一下，还要做好记录，不然不知道正方说什么。

　　OK，你说第一句话。

　　Besides that, the Internet is beneficial because it can provide more opportunities for middle - school students to know about the things that happen in our world. If there's no Internet, middle - school students would be confined to their own environment and they won't know what's happening in the world. So I think the Internet is beneficial.

　　好的。

　　I also think... 什么？你是反方，你怎么了？你不是反方吗？不好意思，我刚刚听错了。

　　Okay, I also don't think the Internet is necessary for middle - school students. Because middle - school students don't have a mature mentality. If they are in their free time, they don't have a strong mentality to control themselves. So I don't think it's necessary for middle - school students to have access to the Internet.

　　自控力就是要管住学生玩手机。所以你需要反驳对方，指出其观点不够全面。同时，你可以向对方提出问题，让其回答。但不能一直提问，应该是一方提问，另一方回答，然后再提问，如此循环，否则感觉像是在“打架”。不过，我可能会卡顿，没关系，自控力，对吧。

　　B：我们认同手机对学生有一定优势。我认为好学生能认识到手机有很多优点，但如果因为手机存在弊端就完全禁止使用，这对中学生群体并非有益。

　　A：你认为手机对学生有益，但我不这么觉得。因为手机就像一把双刃剑，有时会对学生造成伤害。如果学生心智不够成熟，就容易沉迷手机，身体也会受到损害。所以我认为应该为学生制定规则，帮助他们培养自控能力，自行解决问题，而不是一味禁止。此外，制定的规则并非适用于所有人，因为每个人都有自己的想法，有时可能不愿意遵循。而且随着互联网的发展，如果禁止学生使用手机，他们可能会寻找其他方式娱乐自己，甚至可能会做一些不太好的事情。过去，家长很难让孩子按时回家，因为孩子可以在外面玩一整天。

　　其实，刚才给反方计时时，我少记了七八秒，当时忘了要给反方计时。比如，你针对我们家二辩提问，那是否也应该向我们家一辩提问呢？没关系，我刚才有点忘了你说的内容。刚才莫妮卡跟我说了些话，然后我就开始发言了。应该可以交叉提问吧。我刚才以为是你和莫妮卡两人一组进行辩论，其实我一开始也是这么想的，但后来不太确定具体形式，所以我重新调整了一下，现在我们两人一起辩论。你可以问我问题。让我想想你的观点，文娜说手机可以作为学习资源和社交工具，我反驳说如果沉迷手机，会破坏人际关系，而且不会用手机学习，只会玩游戏。你来反驳我的观点，并可以提出问题，或者直接反驳我所说的话。

　　A：关于你的观点，你认为互联网会让学生陷入某种状态，影响人际关系。但你是否认为互联网也有助于建立人际关系呢？我认为如果沉迷手机，会导致手机成瘾，总是好奇手机里的内容，而忽略他人的交流，也无法关注外界发生的事情，所以沉迷手机会损害人际关系。

　　B：但互联网也是了解世界的有用工具。我们并非只能通过现实生活了解世界，也可以通过互联网拓宽视野、学习知识。不过，如果沉迷手机，只关注自己感兴趣的信息，就会忽略其他有趣的内容，比如只关注明星动态，而不关注世界上发生的其他事情。这种观点并不全面，虽然有些学生容易沉迷手机，但也有一些学生能够很好地自控，平衡现实生活和网络世界的时间。然而，大多数孩子缺乏自控能力，需要他人帮助。

　　对，所以只有你明白了。时间不够了，那 OK。

　　哎呀，好激烈，还好玩，我也觉得很好玩。哎，等一下我还没开始。哎，Rush rush rush rush。反过来名字之后听不了，我的肉米还能听不了，我们两个的名字啊。

　　怎么了，没有，就是这一分钟是每个人总结自己的观点，还是总结你方观点，不管是谁说出来的，总结自己观点。OK，我的提问突然关机了，要不然我可以回顾一下。

　　And we can balance between the. 那我试一下吧。

　　Uh in conclusion, the Internet can help the middle - school students to learn more things in our world. It can provide more opportunities to promote themselves. Through the Internet, we can search for the information that we want on the Internet. And it's necessary. If it can also filter out some information. So I think the Internet helps students to learn about the things around the world. Through the Internet, the students can learn what happens in the world no matter where they are.

　　他这个是不是 30 秒换一下，30 秒它会提示一下，对，OK。等一下，我想一下。

　　So in summary, I don't agree with the opinions of the other side members. I think the Internet will cause people to be addicted. It will make people focus on the things they like. They can't use useful resources to study because they only want to see what they want. They will ignore other things. That's why it causes addiction. Also, it will break the connection between them and other people because they can't realize others want to interact with them. They immerse themselves in their own world.

　　OK.

　　Want to be addicted to the mobile phone, but there are also some good examples where we can control our use and make better progress with the mobile phone. I think whether some people are addicted to the mobile phone or not is not because of the features of the mobile platform, but because they have difficulties in real life. So it's important for us to help our students learn to face themselves and develop resilience to difficulties, rather than prohibit the use of mobile phones. We all have mobile phones, and there's no doubt that mobile phones help us a lot. Through using them, we gain experiences, learn a great deal, and make much progress.

　　因为我少了，好的，直接到了20。

　　From what has been said, we can conclude that the Internet is not beneficial for everyone, especially for middle - school students. Middle - school students do not have a mature mentality. During their rest time, they are usually stressed and busy with their homework. So if they spend more time on their phones during their rest time, it is easy for them to become addicted to their phones. I don't think it's a good way to take a break.

　　Secondly, the Internet also does harm to middle - school students.

　　那个连连有好几秒我都没记，但是这个还怪有意思的。然后我发现我每次想听你们说话，但是又想着要计时，有时候就没听清你们说的内容。

　　原本设定的时间应该是30秒，怎么改成1分30秒了。好了，开始吧。

　　咱们讨论的话题是“abroad study”。我们还是按照一辩、二辩的顺序进行。直接开始，免得没电了。

　　那我先来。我认为学生应该出国学习。当他们体验不同的文化时，会对世界有更深刻的理解，同时也能拓宽他们的全球视野。此外，我们还能结交外国朋友。所以我觉得这对他们来说是一次非常有意义的经历。

　　而选择不出国学习也并非不可行。如果想了解外国文化，完全可以在网上学习。如果想和外国人交朋友，在学校里也能做到，和留学生打个招呼就行。如果身处国外，情况又会怎样呢？

　　我认为学生应该出国学习，这能提供更多了解不同文化的机会。对他们来说，拓宽视野很有必要。因为外国文化与我们本国文化不同，这能让学生了解不同国家的不同思维方式。

　　然而，我并不支持所有学生都出国学习。因为并非每个家庭都有足够的经济实力支持学生出国。而且，出国学习会花费大量时间。此外，如果出国，原有的人际关系可能会疏远。当回国在国内工作时，可能会面临缺乏人脉的问题。

　　我是直接来反驳你的观点的，我当时没说我的观点。你说出国可以学外国的文化，学更多的知识，我则认为在网上也可以学。你还说出国可以交好多外国的好朋友，很有意义，我觉得在学校和留学生打招呼也能实现这一点。

　　If you want to experience a certain culture, I think if you immerse yourself in that environment and stay there for a long time, it's beneficial. However, I think some theories on the Internet or in social media are not that comprehensive. So, if you really want to learn something, you can't just study online at first. Because if you don't know about it, you need to learn it first. You need to understand that the situation of going abroad is very costly, and you need to spend a lot of money, which is not very necessary. Also, if you really want to learn something, there are many online tutoring resources available. You can also research some books to help you and learn deeply.

　　I think the resources in the online environment are very limited. You know, you need to search for information all by yourself. When you go abroad, everything is prepared for you. In the university, the teachers will provide many materials for you, and your classmates can also help you learn the knowledge. In that environment, you study and play with your foreign friends, which can give you a better learning experience.

　　However, in - person classes are not very suitable for everyone. If you learn online and there are things you don't understand, you can watch the video repeatedly. But if you are in an in - person class, it depends on yourself. If you are a very shy person, it may not be very helpful for you. We can't just say that everyone needs to go abroad to study. If you are an active person, I think it's more necessary for you because you can be more active in the new environment, relieve the pressure, and see more. To overcome our disadvantages, we need to spend a lot of time.

　　About your ideas, you think the act of going abroad to study will enable people to make international friends. When they come back, they may have fewer friends in their home country. But do you think that for those who participate in overseas study programs, they will also encounter many friends from the same location and be familiar with the news there?

　　Moreover, it can provide a good environment if we go abroad to work or live. If we want to live and work abroad, we can also study abroad in high school. However, if you want to come back from school and live in our country, but you don't have many relationships here because you've established relationships overseas and have gotten used to living there. At this time, if you come back from foreign countries, it can be regarded as a kind of resource. It's also a good resource to develop better relationships in our country in the future.

　　This is indeed a valuable resource. We can make the most of these relationships and resources. As Chinese people, we usually choose to have close relationships with our family, parents, and other relatives. In contrast, foreigners don't have the same habit of getting along for a long - time.

　　This may give us some suggestions on how to adapt to both our home country and foreign countries. Moreover, going abroad can allow us to learn different things. Can you deny that growing abroad is also a kind of resource to improve our ability?

　　We can learn on the Internet, so we don't have to spend a lot of money and energy to learn. I think that's true.

　　我认为出国留学非常必要，因为它可以拓宽我们对其他国家的认知，更好地了解文化多样性。

　　如果真的想学习国外文化，就需要让自己置身于那种环境中。而且，国外的一切都安排得很周到，资源和资料的质量都很高，无需花费时间在互联网上搜索，节省了时间。

　　此外，留学还能帮助我们在留学国家以及本国拓展人脉。

　　我认为留学可以让我们参加线下课程，但如果之前只能在线学习，也能达到相同的学习水平。而且，如果真的想学习，即便资源有限，也能学好知识。

　　不过，并非每个人都适合出国留学，这需要考虑家庭环境和自身情况。也许有些人出国后会不喜欢，到那时可能会后悔。

　　首先，中学生出国学习有诸多好处。国外能提供更多学习机会，让学生接触不同的人，获得不同的建议以解决问题。如果中学生出国，他们能在国外结交更多朋友，这些人脉资源有助于未来职业发展。所以，我认为中学生有必要出国学习，去了解与本国不同的事物。

　　然而，出国学习也存在弊端。虽然出国学习是一种资源，但并非对每个人都适用。如果要出国生活和学习，需要花费大量时间，而且回国后，与国外朋友的关系可能会疏远，只能通过网络交流，不利于维持人际关系。

　　其次，并非每个家庭都有足够的经济实力支持孩子出国学习。所以，出国学习对很多人来说是一种昂贵的选择。