Because books are very authentic. If you can get what you want from some novels, you can experience different lives. With your experience and from teachers, teachers usually teach face - to - face. If you have any confusion, you can just get an answer from the teacher in person.

　　So, I think books and teachers are very important to our students. I think students should learn from books and their teachers. The knowledge in our books is the crystallization of thousands of years, and our teachers have more experience than us. As the old saying goes, “I have eaten more salt than you have eaten rice.” Therefore, I think books and teachers are important for students.

　　I think experience is the best teacher in our lives. Just like practicing is much more important than just learning. If a teacher only teaches students how to read but does not let them experience, I think it will slow down the students' progress. A student should learn more from experience and daily life.

　　I think the essence of knowledge, apart from what is in the books and what the teachers teach, actually comes from daily life. What your teachers teach and what the books tell you are actually the experiences from society. So, the essence of learning from books and teachers is actually learning from experience and daily life.

　　The reason is that what the books tell and what your teachers tell are sometimes a bit rigid because they always follow the same pattern in the class. If you can gain experience directly, it will be more beneficial.

　　这个自由辩论环节，我们正反方直接互相提问吧。双方各选两人，然后依次发言。时间肯定会有结束的时候，大家都没话说了自然就结束了。

　　那我先开始。

　　And I don't think the society can teach you everything. You know, it takes you almost a lifetime to understand the essence of society. But if you learn from teachers and books, it only takes a few hours. So it's very efficient to learn from books and teachers. Also, if you are very young, you even can't understand the words, the language, or what money is. So how can you experience the society?

　　好，我先说这些，待会儿再提问，不然问题太多可能记不住。

　　So your first question, or rather your first reason, is that the efficiency of learning from books and teachers is higher, while learning from experience and daily life is lower. Actually, I think what you think is reasonable to some extent, but it's not always true. You know, experience and daily life are like a book without a cover, and there are things you can only learn from experience and your daily life. And teachers cannot always be the source of all knowledge.

　　And your second reason is that when we are young, we learn how to see, how to speak, and how to work. This is not from books or teachers; it's actually from our experience and daily life. Don't you think learning from experience is more efficient?

　　Well, if teachers are not useful, why do we still need them? We don't say we don't need teachers. We just say that we can rely more on our experience than on books and teachers because experience is the best teacher in our life. And you should pay attention that the topic here is to learn more, not to learn only. Actually, both books and teachers are very important, but that doesn't mean we can learn everything from books and teachers.

　　The experience and daily life are essential in our lives. Yes, you said we can't always learn from books and teachers. But we can also learn from experience and daily life all the time. As students, we can learn from books and teachers when we don't have enough time to gain experience. Sometimes, we may let our teachers and books tell us things.

　　Okay, that's all. Actually, we don't say we should spend all our time on experience, but more time than we spend with books and teachers. Because if we learn something from books, we need experience to enrich our knowledge. For example, when we were children, our parents might give us some story - books to read. When we go to college, we need to study books, and our teachers are still there. You may think it's more important to spend time with books and teachers, but it doesn't mean we should learn more from them.

　　Do you think the knowledge learned from books and teachers is very useful and really beneficial for you in the future? Do you think it will bring you a lot of money and more freedom? Our society always encourages us to read books. Similarly, experience is also important. You can't always stay in one environment. If you want to change and improve yourself, you need to read some books.

　　Yes, you can improve yourself, but why do you have to learn from books instead of from experience? Sometimes we don't have the time to test mistakes through experience. You may learn more things in a few days from experience, but from a book, you may take a long time to learn about a certain thing. You said books are sometimes not useful. I don't think so. I can learn whatever I want. If I think something is useful, I'll learn from books and teachers; if not, I won't.

　　Another thing is, for example, my mom always works in the factory. If she wants to improve herself at work, I think she should read some books rather than just rely on experience. Books and teachers are not always the same. I need to make a distinction, and I think books and teachers can teach us a lot.