the development of AI is more benificial the development of AI is more harmful
only one heart"Tribute to Science" Billingual Inter-school Tournament2024年11月30日阅读量：0
scientific exploration
阅读量：0
So, let's invite our first speaker from the affirmative side. You will have three minutes to start.
So, let's invite our first speaker from the affirmative side. You will have three minutes to start.
以下为ai总结(感谢来自 刘圣韬 学长的精彩ai prompt！基座大模型为豆包。)
重要概念定义
- AI发展有益：指人工智能在各个领域的发展带来的积极影响，包括但不限于提高生产效率、改善生活质量、推动科学研究进展等。
- AI发展有害：指人工智能发展过程中产生的负面效应，像导致部分人失业、存在隐私泄露风险、可能被恶意利用等。
判断标准
- 从对人类社会整体的长远影响来判断，包括社会、经济、文化、伦理等多方面的综合考量，如果在这些方面带来的积极改变多于消极改变，则认为AI发展更有益；反之则认为更有害。
分论点与事实佐证
- 分论点1：提高生产效率
- 事实佐证：在工业领域，AI机器人可以24小时不间断工作，例如汽车制造工厂中，AI控制的机械臂能够精准快速地完成焊接、组装等工作，大大提高了汽车的生产速度和质量。
- 分论点如何服务于判断标准：生产效率的提高是社会经济发展的重要因素，从长远来看，这有助于提升整个社会的财富水平，对人类社会整体的经济方面有着积极的推动作用，符合从人类社会整体长远影响判断的标准。
- 分论点2：改善生活质量
- 事实佐证：智能家居系统利用AI技术，人们可以通过语音控制家电设备，如调节室内温度、开关灯光等，方便了人们的日常生活。在医疗领域，AI辅助诊断系统能够快速准确地分析病情，为患者提供更好的医疗服务。
- 分论点如何服务于判断标准：这些应用直接改善了人们的生活体验，在社会生活方面给人类带来了积极的影响，从人类社会整体长远影响来看，是有利于人类社会发展的，符合判断标准。
- 分论点3：推动科学研究进展
- 事实佐证：在天文学研究中，AI算法可以处理海量的观测数据，帮助科学家更快地发现新的天体和星系；在基因研究方面，AI技术能够分析基因序列，加速对疾病基因的探索。
- 分论点如何服务于判断标准：科学研究的进展对人类社会的发展有着深远意义，无论是对宇宙的探索还是对人类自身健康的研究，都有助于人类社会在文化、科技等多方面的长远发展，符合从人类社会整体长远影响判断的标准。
结论
综上所述，从对人类社会整体的长远影响的判断标准来看，AI发展在提高生产效率、改善生活质量、推动科学研究进展等多方面带来了积极的影响，所以AI的发展是更有益的。
本环节金句
- 在工业领域，AI机器人可以24小时不间断工作，例如汽车制造工厂中，AI控制的机械臂能够精准快速地完成焊接、组装等工作，大大提高了汽车的生产速度和质量。
- 智能家居系统利用AI技术，人们可以通过语音控制家电设备，如调节室内温度、开关灯光等，方便了人们的日常生活。
- 在天文学研究中，AI算法可以处理海量的观测数据，帮助科学家更快地发现新的天体和星系。
The statement. The quiet speaker from the affirmative side was about to start. But before that, I will let you know. Please pay attention. This means you will only have thirty seconds. OK. The next part is very important. Because when you reach seventy, it means China's turn. Let me make that clear. OK, good. OK, let's start our opening statement.
The statement. The quiet speaker from the affirmative side was about to start. But before that, I will let you know. Please pay attention. This means you will only have thirty seconds. OK. The next part is very important. Because when you reach seventy, it means China's turn. Let me make that clear. OK, good. OK, let's start our opening statement.
以下为ai总结(感谢来自 刘圣韬 学长的精彩ai prompt！基座大模型为豆包。)
你提供的这段文本只是关于辩论开场的一些说明性话语，并没有实际的辩论文本内容，请提供完整的辩论文本以便我进行分析。
Thank you. Next, we will proceed to the cross - examination. The second speaker from the negative side will cross - examine the first speaker from the positive side.
So, my question is this: in your view, how do you see the issue of society? You seem to have ignored the fact that there is a decrease in income and population, and there are also problems in employment. So, how can this situation continue? We still have eighteen minutes and seconds left.
Thank you. Next, we will proceed to the cross - examination. The second speaker from the negative side will cross - examine the first speaker from the positive side.
So, my question is this: in your view, how do you see the issue of society? You seem to have ignored the fact that there is a decrease in income and population, and there are also problems in employment. So, how can this situation continue? We still have eighteen minutes and seconds left.
以下为ai总结(感谢来自 刘圣韬 学长的精彩ai prompt！基座大模型为豆包。)
以下是双方讨论流程：
- 反方二辩开始质询，提出问题。反方二辩指出正方一辩似乎忽略了社会中存在收入和人口减少以及就业问题的事实，并询问在这种情况下正方认为当前的情况如何能够持续发展。
- 正方一辩尚未做出回应（根据提供文本），且此时还剩余18分钟（推测是该环节剩余时间）。
All right, thank you. Now let's move on to the opening statement by the negative side. The first speaker from the negative side will have three minutes.
All right, thank you. Now let's move on to the opening statement by the negative side. The first speaker from the negative side will have three minutes.
以下为ai总结(感谢来自 刘圣韬 学长的精彩ai prompt！基座大模型为豆包。)
由于你提供的这段文本只是主持人介绍反方一辩开场陈述环节的话语，并没有反方一辩的实际辩论文本内容，请提供反方一辩的辩论文本内容以便我进行分析。
Next, we will proceed to the cross - examination. The second speaker from the affirmative side will cross - examine the first speaker on the negative side.
First, I will ask you the first question. AI is able to improve the quality of job employment. For example, using algorithms and projects can provide drivers with something. What? Do you want to continue this time?
Next, we will proceed to the cross - examination. The second speaker from the affirmative side will cross - examine the first speaker on the negative side.
First, I will ask you the first question. AI is able to improve the quality of job employment. For example, using algorithms and projects can provide drivers with something. What? Do you want to continue this time?
以下为ai总结(感谢来自 刘圣韬 学长的精彩ai prompt！基座大模型为豆包。)
以下是双方讨论流程：
- 正方二辩开启质询环节，表示AI能够提高就业质量，例如利用算法和项目可以为司机提供某些东西（未明确指出），并询问反方一辩是否要继续。
Thank you all for the speeches. Now we will enter the summary of the cross - examination. Let's welcome the representative from the negative side. They will start first. You will have ninety seconds to give your speech. Different jobs, no income, and less population. What we are up against is not one that will not stop, but one that must. Our first point is much more than you.
Thank you all for the speeches. Now we will enter the summary of the cross - examination. Let's welcome the representative from the negative side. They will start first. You will have ninety seconds to give your speech. Different jobs, no income, and less population. What we are up against is not one that will not stop, but one that must. Our first point is much more than you.
以下为ai总结(感谢来自 刘圣韬 学长的精彩ai prompt！基座大模型为豆包。)
以下是双方讨论流程： 反方首先提到“不同的工作、没有收入、人口减少”这些情况，然后表示所面临的（可能指AI发展带来的状况）不是不会停止的，而是必然的，最后提出自己的第一点（但未明确指出第一点的具体内容，只是表示比对方多）。
The second speaker from the affirmative side. In this Summary of Cross - Examination, we have ninety seconds. Regarding what you said, it is overboard. However, we don't need to worry about it because our government will do something to protect employment. And the only reason for some people being unemployed at certain times, such as in the United States, is due to various factors. Thank you for your speech.
The second speaker from the affirmative side. In this Summary of Cross - Examination, we have ninety seconds. Regarding what you said, it is overboard. However, we don't need to worry about it because our government will do something to protect employment. And the only reason for some people being unemployed at certain times, such as in the United States, is due to various factors. Thank you for your speech.
以下为ai总结(感谢来自 刘圣韬 学长的精彩ai prompt！基座大模型为豆包。)
攻击和防御的概括
- 攻击：指出对方言论过于偏激（未明确指出对方具体言论内容）。
- 防御：强调政府会采取措施保护就业，并且认为美国某些时候有人失业是多种因素导致的，以此来反驳AI发展有害的观点（隐含逻辑为AI发展可能带来失业问题，但这不是AI发展本身的问题，有其他因素影响且政府会解决就业问题，所以AI发展是有益的）。
本环节金句
- Regarding what you said, it is overboard.
- However, we don't need to worry about it because our government will do something to protect employment.
- And the only reason for some people being unemployed at certain times, such as in the United States, is due to various factors.
We will move on to the point - to - point debate in this session. Each side has one hundred and ninety seconds. The speeches of both parties are organized in such a way that when one party ends their speech, the other begins to speak. Once the time has expired, the other side can continue the speech until their time is up.
Now, on your side, your time starts. Have a better education... Now talk about... So sorry... And can go... Time for priority on increasing... Including all through this group... So therefore...
We will move on to the point - to - point debate in this session. Each side has one hundred and ninety seconds. The speeches of both parties are organized in such a way that when one party ends their speech, the other begins to speak. Once the time has expired, the other side can continue the speech until their time is up.
Now, on your side, your time starts. Have a better education... Now talk about... So sorry... And can go... Time for priority on increasing... Including all through this group... So therefore...
以下为ai总结(感谢来自 刘圣韬 学长的精彩ai prompt！基座大模型为豆包。)
由于这段文本内容非常不清晰且缺乏明确的观点阐述，无法按照要求进行正常的分析，只能给出双方的讨论流程：
- 正方三辩开始发言，但是由于语音转写内容混乱，无法明确其确切观点。
- 正方三辩发言过程中可能出现一些表述不清或者错误（如“Have a better education... Now talk about... So sorry... And can go... Time for priority on increasing... Including all through this group... So therefore...”这些表述语义不明）。
- 正方三辩时间到后，反方三辩开始发言（但文本未给出反方三辩内容）。
Thank you all for the speeches. Now, let's enter the summary session of the point - to - point phase. First, I will invite the affirmative side. You will have nine (minutes).
Thank you all for the speeches. Now, let's enter the summary session of the point - to - point phase. First, I will invite the affirmative side. You will have nine (minutes).
以下为ai总结(感谢来自 刘圣韬 学长的精彩ai prompt！基座大模型为豆包。)
由于提供的文本只是正方三辩环节开始的引入部分，没有实际的辩论内容，无法按照要求进行分析，请提供完整的正方三辩的辩论文本内容以便我进行分析。
Let's switch to the negative. We will have 97 (此处表述不太清晰，可能存在错误，但按要求忠实于原文) of you. Those people think we need to consider humanity over the potential of job increase and the erosion of meaningful work. These are challenges that should require action.
Let's switch to the negative. We will have 97 (此处表述不太清晰，可能存在错误，但按要求忠实于原文) of you. Those people think we need to consider humanity over the potential of job increase and the erosion of meaningful work. These are challenges that should require action.
以下为ai总结(感谢来自 刘圣韬 学长的精彩ai prompt！基座大模型为豆包。)
攻击和防御的概括
- 攻击：指出有部分人认为相比人工智能发展带来的就业增加潜力，应该更优先考虑人性，同时提到人工智能发展会对有意义的工作造成侵蚀，这些都是需要采取行动应对的挑战，暗示人工智能发展是有害的，反驳正方可能提出的人工智能发展有益（如就业增加方面）的观点。
- 防御：未明确体现针对正方攻击的防御内容，主要是在强调己方关于人工智能发展有害的观点。
本环节金句
- “Those people think we need to consider humanity over the potential of job increase.”
- “These are challenges that should require action.”
辩题：the development of AI is more benificial vs the development of AI is more harmful 环节：Free Debate
以下为处理后的文本： Thank you all. Let's move to our free debate session. Each side will have a lot of time. Some people, in this generation, are concerned about AI. Do you want to continue?
辩题：the development of AI is more benificial vs the development of AI is more harmful 环节：Free Debate
以下为处理后的文本： Thank you all. Let's move to our free debate session. Each side will have a lot of time. Some people, in this generation, are concerned about AI. Do you want to continue?
以下为ai总结(感谢来自 刘圣韬 学长的精彩ai prompt！基座大模型为豆包。)
这只是自由辩论环节的开场引导语，并非实质性的辩论内容，没有双方的观点交锋等内容，无法按照要求进行分析。请提供完整的自由辩论环节的语音转写文本内容以便进行分析。
Now we move to the concluding session. In this session, we have three minutes to make our final statement. We will start with the fourth speaker from the proposition side.
Now we move to the concluding session. In this session, we have three minutes to make our final statement. We will start with the fourth speaker from the proposition side.
以下为ai总结(感谢来自 刘圣韬 学长的精彩ai prompt！基座大模型为豆包。)
重要概念定义
- AI发展有益（the development of AI is more benificial）：指人工智能在多个领域如医疗、教育、工业等方面带来积极的影响，包括提高效率、改善生活质量、推动科学研究等。
- AI发展有害（the development of AI is more harmful）：意味着人工智能在发展过程中对人类社会产生诸如就业威胁、伦理道德挑战、安全风险等负面的影响。
判断标准
- 从对人类社会整体的长远发展（包括经济、社会、文化、伦理等多方面）的影响来判断AI发展是更有益还是更有害。
分论点与事实佐证
- 提高生产效率与生活质量。
- 事实佐证：在工业领域，AI机器人可以24小时不间断工作，提高生产效率，减少人力成本；在智能家居方面，AI技术让人们可以通过语音控制家电，方便生活。
- 分论点如何服务于判断标准：提高生产效率有助于推动经济发展，改善生活质量是对人类社会发展积极影响的体现，符合从人类社会整体长远发展来判断的标准。
- 推动科学研究进展。
- 事实佐证：AI可以处理海量的数据，在天文学中帮助分析星系数据，在医学研究中协助分析基因数据等。
- 分论点如何服务于判断标准：科学研究的进展是人类社会发展的重要动力，AI在这方面的推动作用表明其对人类社会整体长远发展有着积极意义。
- 创造新的就业机会。
- 事实佐证：虽然AI取代了一些传统工作，但也催生了如AI工程师、数据分析师、AI伦理研究员等新职业。
- 分论点如何服务于判断标准：新的就业机会有助于社会稳定和经济发展，从人类社会整体长远发展来看是有益的方面。
结论
综上所述，从对人类社会整体的长远发展的多方面影响来看，AI发展带来的积极影响更多，所以AI的发展是更有益的。
本环节金句
- 在工业领域，AI机器人可以24小时不间断工作，提高生产效率，减少人力成本，这体现了AI发展对经济发展的积极推动作用。
- 虽然AI取代了一些传统工作，但也催生了如AI工程师、数据分析师、AI伦理研究员等新职业，说明AI发展也在创造新的就业机会。
- AI可以处理海量的数据，在天文学中帮助分析星系数据，在医学研究中协助分析基因数据等，这表明AI对推动科学研究进展有着重要意义。
